| |
Evacuated Tubes |
Flat Plate Collectors |
Basic System Layout |
Evacuated Tube Solar Collectors
are hermetically sealed within
a vacuum sealed glass tube.
This eliminates convection and
conduction heat losses, and
also isolates the collectors from
any adverse weather conditions
outside. |
These collectors are built within
a solid, sealed case, and covered
with a tough tempered glass facing
which helps to protect them
from the elements. However,
the air gap within the collector
can lead to conduction and convection
heat losses, especially on
cold and windy days. |
Heat Loss Protection |
Evacuated Tube Solar Collectors
use a heat pipe for super-efficient conduction and transfer.
No water ever touches the solar
collectors, eliminating corrosion
and effi ciency losses. |
Flat Plate Solar Collectors circulated
water through insulated
areas within the collector. This
makes them more prone to leakage,
corrosion, and restricted
flow. |
|
The heat pipe of an evacuated
tube solar collector is safeguarded
from overheating by
the conduction properties of the
special heating fl uid within it.
This overheat protection keeps
your system safe from accidental
heat damage. |
Flat Plate Solar Collectors have
no internal overheat protection
methods in place, and rely solely
on exterior overheat limitors. If
these methods fail, damage can
occur to the system. |
Ease of Installation |
Evacuated Tube Solar Collectors
are easy to install, and can be
carried to the job site, and onto
the roof in pieces for a lighter,
easier workload. Additionally,
if one tube becomes damaged,
only that tube needs to be replaced. |
Flat Plate Collectors must be
installed in one solid unit, and
must be brought to the jobsite
and onto the roof that way. Also,
when a portion of a collector
fails, the entire collector must be
shut down and replaced. |
System Design
& Placement
|
Because of their 360 degree collector
design, evacuated tube
solar collectors are relatively
adept at accepting most installation
angles. This allows for more
freedom and aesthetics in the
system design and installation. |
Flat Plate Collectors, like PV Panels,
need to be placed directly
at 12 degrees off south, and at
roughly the same angle as the
location's latitude. This means
there are far fewer options for
the installation, and aesthetics
must often be sacrifi ced in order
to protect performance. |
Climate Types |
Evacuated Tube Solar Collectors
are perfect for nearly any
climate, but really shine in
northern climates with cooler
temperatures, shorter days, and
lower sun angles. |
Flat Plate Solar Collectors can
be used in most climates, but
are signifi cantly more eff ective
in warmer, sunnier, southern climates,
where freezing and solar
angle are less likely to impact a
solar water heating system. |
Investment & Cost Effectiveness |
Evacuated Tube Solar Collectors
are often more expensive initially
that Flat Plate Solar Collectors,
but this investment will often
be recouped quickly due to the
increased performance of these
collectors in a wider variety of
climates and conditions. |
Flat Plate Solar Collectors typically
cost less from the outset
than Evacuated Tubes. However,
the lower performance ratings
in many climates, and increased
maintenance and replacement
costs mean that they are generally
less cost-eff ective than
Evacuated Tube Collectors. |
We
Recommend
|
We recommend Evacuated Tube
Solar Collectors for our clients
anywhere where cold weather,
and possible freezing is a significant factor in the weather. |
We recommend Flat Plate Solar
Collectors to our clients who
live in souther climates where
freezing is unlikely, and where
solar angles, and the amount of
sunlight does not justify the increased
investment of an Evacuated
Tube Solar Collector. |